- Title Pages
- Illustration
- Preface
- Abbreviations
- Notes on Contributors
- Encomium
- ‘Forward into the Past’
- The Academic Publications of M. L. West
- 1 Terminal Problems
- 2 The Monster and the Monologue: Polyphemus from Homer to Ovid
- 3 Low Words in High Places: Sex, Bodily Functions, and Body Parts in Homeric Epic and Other Higher Genres
- 4 Smileumata Iliaka: Three Puzzling Verses
- 5 Hesiod’s <i>Theogony</i> and the Folk Tale
- 6 The Homeric Hymn to Hermes
- 7 Night Thoughts (Archilochus 23 and 196a West)
- 8 A Human Fable and the Justice of Beasts in Archilochus
- 9 Hipponactea quaedam
- 10 Pindaric Accompaniments
- 11 Lucian and Archilochus, or: How to Make Use of the Ancient Iambographers in the Context of the Second Sophistic
- 12 Housman’s Greek
- 13 Greek Tragedy: Text and Context
- 14 Desperate Straits and the Tragic Stage
- 15 Sophocles’ Learning Curve
- 16 ‘Darkness, my Light’: Enigmatic Ajax
- 17 Problems in the Prologue and Parodos of <i>Bacchae</i>
- 18 Tragic Interpolation and Philip II: Pylades’ Forgotten Exile and Other Problems in Euripides’ Orestes
- 19 Some Poetic Connections of Lycophron’s Alexandra
- 20 Dionysius’ Ear
- 21 What’s in a Line? Papyrus Formats and Hephaestionic Formulae
- 22 Reconstructing Archetypes: A New Proposal and an Old Fallacy
- 23 Critical Notes on the Greek Paroemiographers
- 24 Erasmus on Homer’s Moly<sup>*</sup>
- 25 Homage to G&R 2nd ser. 11 (1964): 185–7 or The Sibyl Prophesies the Slaying of the Jabberwock
- Bibliography
- <i>Index Locorum</i>
- <i>Index of Greek Words</i>
- <i>General Index</i>
Lucian and Archilochus, or: How to Make Use of the Ancient Iambographers in the Context of the Second Sophistic
Lucian and Archilochus, or: How to Make Use of the Ancient Iambographers in the Context of the Second Sophistic
- Chapter:
- (p.132) 11 Lucian and Archilochus, or: How to Make Use of the Ancient Iambographers in the Context of the Second Sophistic
- Source:
- Hesperos
- Author(s):
Heinz-Günther Nesselrath
- Publisher:
- Oxford University Press
Lucian's pamphlet ‘The Mistaken Critic, or: On the nefarious day’ is one of the most vitriolic pieces of invective in ancient Greek literature. The enemy that Lucian demolishes in this pamphlet apparently made the mistake of taking Lucian to task on a topic where the versatile Greek satirist hailing from Syrian Samosata was most sensitive: he dared question Lucian's competence in the subtleties of Greek style and expression, contending that Lucian had used the word άποφράς (meaning ‘unlucky/ill-omened’) in an inappropriate and ‘barbarous’ way. Being called a ‘barbaros’ in matters of language was one of the things Lucian liked least, and in ‘The Mistaken Critic’ he pounced upon his adversary with savage delight, insulting every bit of his opponent's character and life and demonstrating his own mastery of Greek prose style at the same time. This chapter focuses on how Lucian starts his rhetorical demolition work, namely by invoking Archilochus.
Keywords: Lucian, Archilochus, The Mistaken Critic, rhetoric, barbaros
Oxford Scholarship Online requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books within the service. Public users can however freely search the site and view the abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter.
Please, subscribe or login to access full text content.
If you think you should have access to this title, please contact your librarian.
To troubleshoot, please check our FAQs , and if you can't find the answer there, please contact us .
- Title Pages
- Illustration
- Preface
- Abbreviations
- Notes on Contributors
- Encomium
- ‘Forward into the Past’
- The Academic Publications of M. L. West
- 1 Terminal Problems
- 2 The Monster and the Monologue: Polyphemus from Homer to Ovid
- 3 Low Words in High Places: Sex, Bodily Functions, and Body Parts in Homeric Epic and Other Higher Genres
- 4 Smileumata Iliaka: Three Puzzling Verses
- 5 Hesiod’s <i>Theogony</i> and the Folk Tale
- 6 The Homeric Hymn to Hermes
- 7 Night Thoughts (Archilochus 23 and 196a West)
- 8 A Human Fable and the Justice of Beasts in Archilochus
- 9 Hipponactea quaedam
- 10 Pindaric Accompaniments
- 11 Lucian and Archilochus, or: How to Make Use of the Ancient Iambographers in the Context of the Second Sophistic
- 12 Housman’s Greek
- 13 Greek Tragedy: Text and Context
- 14 Desperate Straits and the Tragic Stage
- 15 Sophocles’ Learning Curve
- 16 ‘Darkness, my Light’: Enigmatic Ajax
- 17 Problems in the Prologue and Parodos of <i>Bacchae</i>
- 18 Tragic Interpolation and Philip II: Pylades’ Forgotten Exile and Other Problems in Euripides’ Orestes
- 19 Some Poetic Connections of Lycophron’s Alexandra
- 20 Dionysius’ Ear
- 21 What’s in a Line? Papyrus Formats and Hephaestionic Formulae
- 22 Reconstructing Archetypes: A New Proposal and an Old Fallacy
- 23 Critical Notes on the Greek Paroemiographers
- 24 Erasmus on Homer’s Moly<sup>*</sup>
- 25 Homage to G&R 2nd ser. 11 (1964): 185–7 or The Sibyl Prophesies the Slaying of the Jabberwock
- Bibliography
- <i>Index Locorum</i>
- <i>Index of Greek Words</i>
- <i>General Index</i>