This book examines some of the key features of what may be called the paradox of constitutionalism: whether those who have the authority to make a constitution — the ‘constitutive power’ — can do so without effectively surrendering that authority to the institutional sites of power ‘constituted’ by the constitutional form they enact. In particular, is the constitutive power exhausted in the single constitutive act or does it retain a presence, acting as critical check on the constitutional operating system and/or an alternative source of authority to be invoked in moments of crisis? These ques ... More

This book examines some of the key features of what may be called the paradox of constitutionalism: whether those who have the authority to make a constitution — the ‘constitutive power’ — can do so without effectively surrendering that authority to the institutional sites of power ‘constituted’ by the constitutional form they enact. In particular, is the constitutive power exhausted in the single constitutive act or does it retain a presence, acting as critical check on the constitutional operating system and/or an alternative source of authority to be invoked in moments of crisis? These questions have been debated both in different national contexts and at the level of constitutional theory, and these debates are acknowledged and developed in the first two sections of the book. Part I includes chapters on how the question of constituent power has been treated in the constitutional histories of USA, France, UK, and Germany, while Part II examines at the question of constituent power from the perspective of both liberal and non-liberal theories of the state and legal order. The essays in Part III consider the operation of constitutionalism with respect to a series of contemporary challenges to the state, including those from popular movements below the level of the state and challenges from the supranational and international levels, and they analyse how the puzzles associated with the question of constituent power are played out in these increasingly important settings.