- Title Pages
- Contributors
- Foreword
- Acknowledgements
- William Schabas
- 1 Human Rights and International Criminal Justice in the Twenty-First Century
- 2 William Schabas, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and International Human Rights Law
- 3 The International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance, as a Victim-Oriented Treaty
- 4 The Politics of Sectarianism and Its Reflection in Questions of International Law and State Formation in the Middle East
- 5 International Law and the Death Penalty
- 6 The UN Optional Protocol on the Abolition of the Death Penalty
- 7 The Right to Life and the Progressive Abolition of the Death Penalty
- 8 Progress and Trend of the Reform of the Death Penalty in China
- 9 Criminal Law Philosophy in William Schabas’s Scholarship
- 10 Is the ICC Focusing Too Much on Non-State Actors?
- 11 The Principle of Legality at the Crossroads of Human Rights and International Criminal Law
- 12 Revisiting the Sources of Applicable Law before the ICC
- 13 The ICC as a Work in Progress, for a World in Process
- 14 Legacy in International Criminal Justice
- 15 Torture by Private Actors and ‘Gold-Plating’ the Offence in National Law
- 16 Secrets and Surprises in the <i>Travaux Préparatoires</i> of the Genocide Convention
- 17 Perspectives on Cultural Genocide
- 18 Crimes against Humanity
- 19 A New Global Treaty on Crimes Against Humanity Future Prospects
- 20 Justice outside of Criminal Courtrooms and Jailhouses
- 21 Toward Greater Synergy between Courts and Truth Commissions in Post-conflict Contexts
- 22 International Criminal Tribunals and Cooperation with States
- 23 The Arc toward Justice <i>and</i> Peace
- 24 The Maintenance of International Peace and Security through Prevention of Atrocity Crimes
- 25 Law and Film
- 26 The Role of Advocates in Developing International Law
- 27 Bill the Blogger
- Index
Criminal Law Philosophy in William Schabas’s Scholarship
Criminal Law Philosophy in William Schabas’s Scholarship
- Chapter:
- (p.155) 9 Criminal Law Philosophy in William Schabas’s Scholarship
- Source:
- Arcs of Global Justice
- Author(s):
Margaret M. deGuzman
- Publisher:
- Oxford University Press
This chapter examines the deontological and consequentialist strains in William Schabas’s scholarship in an effort to illuminate the role that criminal law philosophy plays in much of the international criminal law scholarship. The first section analyses Schabas’s writings on the question of what crimes should be considered international. Schabas’s answer to this question rests heavily on his concern that crimes committed pursuant to a state plan or policy will likely go unpunished if they are not prosecuted at international courts—a consequentialist approach. The second section of the chapter addresses Schabas’s views on which cases international courts should prosecute from among the many cases within their jurisdictions. Schabas approaches this question from a decidedly deontological perspective. This mix of consequentialist and deontological thinking is typical of international criminal law scholarship.
Keywords: international criminal law, philosophy, utilitarianism, deterrence, retribution, deontology, state policy, case selection, victors’ justice, politics
Oxford Scholarship Online requires a subscription or purchase to access the full text of books within the service. Public users can however freely search the site and view the abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter.
Please, subscribe or login to access full text content.
If you think you should have access to this title, please contact your librarian.
To troubleshoot, please check our FAQs , and if you can't find the answer there, please contact us .
- Title Pages
- Contributors
- Foreword
- Acknowledgements
- William Schabas
- 1 Human Rights and International Criminal Justice in the Twenty-First Century
- 2 William Schabas, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and International Human Rights Law
- 3 The International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance, as a Victim-Oriented Treaty
- 4 The Politics of Sectarianism and Its Reflection in Questions of International Law and State Formation in the Middle East
- 5 International Law and the Death Penalty
- 6 The UN Optional Protocol on the Abolition of the Death Penalty
- 7 The Right to Life and the Progressive Abolition of the Death Penalty
- 8 Progress and Trend of the Reform of the Death Penalty in China
- 9 Criminal Law Philosophy in William Schabas’s Scholarship
- 10 Is the ICC Focusing Too Much on Non-State Actors?
- 11 The Principle of Legality at the Crossroads of Human Rights and International Criminal Law
- 12 Revisiting the Sources of Applicable Law before the ICC
- 13 The ICC as a Work in Progress, for a World in Process
- 14 Legacy in International Criminal Justice
- 15 Torture by Private Actors and ‘Gold-Plating’ the Offence in National Law
- 16 Secrets and Surprises in the <i>Travaux Préparatoires</i> of the Genocide Convention
- 17 Perspectives on Cultural Genocide
- 18 Crimes against Humanity
- 19 A New Global Treaty on Crimes Against Humanity Future Prospects
- 20 Justice outside of Criminal Courtrooms and Jailhouses
- 21 Toward Greater Synergy between Courts and Truth Commissions in Post-conflict Contexts
- 22 International Criminal Tribunals and Cooperation with States
- 23 The Arc toward Justice <i>and</i> Peace
- 24 The Maintenance of International Peace and Security through Prevention of Atrocity Crimes
- 25 Law and Film
- 26 The Role of Advocates in Developing International Law
- 27 Bill the Blogger
- Index
